Effectiveness of Teletherapy vs In-Person Therapy

In a similar vein, traditional therapy methods may be the better option for you if there are logistical barriers to teletherapy. If your home is not a safe space for you, or if you do not have a private place to communicate at home, you may find yourself benefitting more from in-person therapy. Frozen videos and choppy conversations may make it hard to communicate and cause frustration for both sides.

Telehealth has become well established in the treatment of illnesses, including mental health conditions. Patients with autism, for example, may feel that virtual therapy gives them more control over their environment, Dr. Bufka said. Virtual sessions may also be better for exposure therapy, a psychological treatment that helps patients with conditions like obsessive-compulsive disorder or anxiety confront their fears. Instead of assigning exposure as homework, a therapist can observe it happening in real time. And teletherapy can be a good bridge to in-person sessions for people with severe anxiety or agoraphobia, or who are prone to panic attacks. Therefore, it’s imperative that clients find highly qualifiedtherapists that they trustwho can give them guidance on whether virtual or in-person therapy would be better for their specific condition.

In fact, some find teletherapy even more effective than in-person therapy because they feel more comfortable talking in their home. The technology can be a hurdle for some clients, and teletherapy may not feel as personable as in-person therapy. Online counseling also enables people to see clinicians that don’t live within driving distance.

How much does virtual therapy cost?

Average online therapy options can cost less than $100 per session but vary depending on the provider or virtual network.

It’s not clear which type of remote therapy, like video versus telephone, is best, for example. And many teletherapy trials enroll patients with less severe symptoms, who are more likely to respond to treatment. There is no doubt that face-to-face or traditional therapy is an effective treatment for mental health concerns, as demonstrated by numerous studies spanning over a century.

Online Therapy Vs. In-Person Therapy: What Are the Differences?

Online therapy platforms that offer unlimited messaging let you communicate with your therapist anytime and anywhere you’re connected to the internet. The A.P.A. has recommended that providers take certain steps to reduce the spread of the coronavirus, including spacing out appointments, increasing ventilation, encouraging physical distancing and enforcing masking for everyone. Another financial consideration when making this choice is the external costs of in-person sessions. For example, the cost of commuting to and from your therapist every week is something you should take into account for as well. While some people may feel confident connecting with a therapist in-person, others may feel anxious and more comfortable talking about their feelings and emotions behind a screen or without a face camera.

  • The current evidence indicates that psychotherapy delivered via telehealth may be an alternative to face-to-face psychotherapy for the treatment of less common mental health conditions and physical conditions requiring psychological care.
  • By offering a hybrid of in-person therapy and teletherapy at each location, we strive to produce better health outcomes and establish the best relationship possible with everyone who comes to us for care.
  • Moreover, it saves you the hassle and time of commuting to your therapist’s office.
  • Ultimately, the best therapy option for you depends entirely on your needs.
  • The goal of teletherapy is to offer services to people who can’t or don’t want to leave their own home.
  • But when she reached out to the service provider to get her client’s emergency contact information, she realized the client had listed herself as her emergency contact.

If you’re going to choose between online vs in-person therapy, therapists believe it’s better to choose the latter. While teletherapy or video therapy is more accessible, in-person therapy sessions are still the most effective. Body of research shows that teletherapy is generally just as effective as in-person treatment is for alleviating symptoms of depression.

People who are unable to leave their home for various reasons, such as physical or mental illness, may find online therapy a useful alternative to traditional in-person psychotherapy settings. We’ve tried, tested, and written unbiased reviews of the best online therapy programs including Talkspace, Betterhelp, and Regain. In 2011, the Speech Pathology and Audiology Department at Kent State conducted a pilot study to assess the effectiveness of speech sound disorder intervention delivered by telehealth to school-age children—yielding encouraging results. The truth of the matter is that teletherapy was introduced in the treatment of speech and language disorders long before COVID-19 made it more universal. In fact, The Mayo Clinic endorsed teletherapy in 1997, deeming it “reliable, beneficial, and acceptable to patients with a variety of acquired speech and language disorders,” across medical settings.

Office Hours

Whether you have a severe mental health disorder that requires more intensive care, or you simply prefer to communicate in-person, online therapy is not always the best option. Attending therapy from the comfort of home makes it easier for people to reach out. Opening the floodgates to teletherapy over the course of the pandemic has excessive alcohol consumption can affect bone health made getting mental healthcare that much easier. Now, you can sit in the comfort of your home, sipping on some tea in your pajamas, and get mental health care and support. And you don’t need to worry about finding a babysitter, planning your commute, or struggling with the anxiety that might come with seeing a provider in person.

This is because instead of just the therapists that are close in proximity to you, you can choose to work with any therapist that is licensed in your state. Because of this, it may be easier to search for a therapist with a strong therapeutic alliance when pursuing tele-therapy. Recent studiesfound that the delivery method of therapy (be it in-person, telephone or videoconferencing) did not significantly affect therapeutic alliance of mental health professionals.

teletherapy vs in-person therapy

Punia V, Nasr G, Zagorski V, Lawrence G, Fesler J, Nair D, Najm I. Evidence of a rapid shift in outpatient practice during the COVID-19 pandemic using telemedicine. Pierce BS, Perrin PB, McDonald SD. Pre-COVID-19 deterrents to practicing with videoconferencing telepsychology among psychologists who didn’t. Torales J, O’Higgins M, Castaldelli-Maia JM, Ventriglio A. The outbreak of COVID-19 coronavirus and its impact on global mental health. A total of 3 different scales were used to describe patients’ overall improvement across the studies . A total of 6 scales across 7 studies were used to report outcomes related to symptom severity . For someone who is dealing with severe mental illness or who responds better to intimate environments, in-person therapy may be a better bet.

We are a founding member of WithTherapy – a growing national network of top trusted therapists. “States and private insurers may find that telehealth works pretty smoothly, which could open up an opportunity for advocacy to make some of those changes permanent,” she says. But not when it comes to people that require close and direct treatment or in-person intervention. You can learn more about health behaviors and coping strategies that will lead to better psychological health. Online therapy is even shown to be effective in reducing problem gambling behaviors.

Let’s dig deeper down each of them to help you understand why in-person therapy sessions for couples are still the best way to achieve great results, as told by experts in the field. Mitchell JE, Crosby RD, Wonderlich SA, Crow S, Lancaster K, Simonich H, Swan-Kremeier L, Lysne C, Myers TC. A randomized trial comparing the efficacy of cognitive-behavioral therapy for bulimia nervosa delivered via telemedicine versus face-to-face. Himle MB, Freitag M, Walther M, Franklin SA, Ely L, Woods DW. A randomized pilot trial comparing videoconference versus face-to-face delivery of behavior therapy for childhood tic disorders. King VL, Stoller KB, Kidorf M, Kindbom K, Hursh S, Brady T, Brooner RK. Assessing the effectiveness of an Internet-based videoconferencing platform for delivering intensified substance abuse counseling. Titles and abstracts were screened independently by author pairs against the inclusion criteria. In addition, 1 author retrieved full texts, and 2 authors screened the full texts for inclusion.

Why people choose Online therapy/ Online Counseling?

More important, the attempt to rapidly roll out remote care has exposed the field’s lack of readiness to broadly transition to the new modality. “For patients who have never before sought care from a therapist due to various barriers —including concern about being seen at a physical clinic—the option to obtain services online can be a port of entry into mental health care,” she says. Today, many states require insurance providers to cover online therapy just as they would traditional therapy sessions.

Is online therapy as effective as face-to-face therapy?

Online therapy provides an equally effective option for mental health support as face-to-face therapy. People seeking therapeutic support for anxiety, depression, and other common mental health needs can use virtual or in-person therapy as a support.

“I need the address so that if something happens to them while we’re in session , I know where to send an ambulance,” says Kalai. At this time, experts still recommend in-person talk therapy for the treatment of severe mental illness. So far, multiple studies — though still preliminary — find that online therapy can be equivalent to face-to-face care. This is an important one, Dr. Ortiz said, so if not, start by ensuring you’re making the most of the medium.

The cost of online therapy also varies, depending on the service and level of support you choose. Adriane Kruer, PsyD, licensed clinical psychologist and owner of Echeveria Therapy Collective, says she charges the same amount for online and in-person therapy since the patient gets the same time and attention. And Kalai confirms that most therapist she knows also charge the same for online and in-person visits. Whether you’re considering online therapy services yourself or have yet to start your therapy search, here’s what you need to know about the differences between online therapy and in-person therapy and what their pros and cons are.

To facilitate that care, Medicare, Medicaid, private insurance companies, and state and federal regulatory agencies temporarily relaxed rules on telehealth. Online therapy offers access to mental health treatment to people in rural or remote areas. Those who live in rural areas simply might not have access to any other form of mental health treatment because there are few or no mental health practices in their area. Research shows that online therapy can be just as effective as in-person therapy for various mental health conditions. They also give your therapist much more information when tailoring sessions.

Disadvantages of Online Therapy

If you’re juggling a hectic schedule, online therapy is a much more convenient option than traditional therapy. Instead of commuting to your therapist’s office every week, you can log into a website or therapy app from the comfort of your own home. Many online therapists offer flexible scheduling options, including evening and weekend appointments so that you may be able to choose the best appointment time for your schedule. Online therapy is also a convenient option for people who struggle to access in-person therapy sessions. It can be especially helpful for clients who lack transportation, live far from specialists, or have a disability.

teletherapy vs in-person therapy

The funder was involved in the refining of the study question in Population, Intervention, Comparator, Outcome format. The funder was not involved in the conduct, analysis, or interpretation of the systematic review or in the decision to submit the manuscript for publication. Overall, of the 12 studies, 10 (83%) adequately reported on random sequence generation and selective reporting.

Search Results

In contrast, clients who live in rural areas can have a much harder time finding high quality providers for in-person services. This scarcity is particularly felt if a client in a rural area needs highly specialized psychotherapy services. In-person psychotherapy enables the use of more treatment modalities compared to online therapy. With in-person services, clients can experience how does alcohol affect stroke risk study investigates therapy through additional senses, and therapists may be more effective with certain interventions such as EMDR, psychodrama, and movement-based therapy. COVID-19 is causing additional stress and also forcing many people to stay in their homes. If you’re considering virtual therapy sessions, you may have questions about how they’re different from traditional in-person sessions.

It is important to rigorously assess whether its effectiveness is generalizable beyond these groups. During the COVID-19 pandemic, because in-person therapy was no longer a viable option, online therapy, also known as virtual or tele-therapy, started pharmacological approaches to reducing craving in patients with alcohol use disorders to gain popularity. Since then, tele-therapy remains a very popular option of mental health care because of it’s convenience for individuals and mental health professionals alike to access and provide mental health treatment from home.

Online Therapy vs. In-Person Therapy: What are the pros and cons?

A study in the United States found that before the COVID-19 pandemic, psychologists were hesitant to use telehealth owing to lack of training, concerns for client safety, and privacy, among other concerns . In addition, a qualitative study of mental health professionals highlighted concerns around the quality of the patient-therapist relationship . Given the health risks posed by face-to-face meetings, especially for older people or otherwise vulnerable, there was a rapid shift to remote delivery in health care services worldwide [9-12]. The popularity of telehealth and teletherapy services increased during the pandemic, mostly out of necessity.

We offer a full array of executive and physician leadership search solutions. Leadership Search We offer a full array of executive and physician leadership search solutions. These are great things to consider before getting decided with your spouse. Ultimately, the best therapy option for you depends entirely on your needs. The goal is always to get the most out of resources and limit the obstacles in your path.